New Hyde Park Diner Menu

160 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, United States
$$$ Diner
(898 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Introducing the menu at New Hyde Park Diner, a culinary gem nestled at 160 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY. This classic diner excels in providing a warm and welcoming atmosphere that reflects old New York charm. Upon entering, guests are greeted with prompt service and refreshing cold water, setting the tone for an enjoyable experience.

The menu offers a delightful array of options to satisfy every palate. From hearty breakfast fare to comforting lunch and dinner selections, each dish is prepared fresh and served in generous portions. Signature items like the tuna melt and cheese blintzes have won over the hearts of many, with reviews praising their deliciousness and value.

Beverage lovers will appreciate the diverse drink menu, featuring everything from classic coffee to decadent cappuccinos, ensuring a perfect pairing with your meal. New Hyde Park Diner promises quality, friendliness, and an undeniable sense of nostalgia—making it a must-visit destination for food enthusiasts.

Homemade Chili

  • Homemade Chili
    US$5.95

Desserts

  • Apple, Cherry or Blueberry Pie
    US$3.25
  • Apple Crumb Cake
    US$3.25
  • Apple Turnover
    US$3.25
  • Banana Cream Pie
    US$3.25
  • Boston Cream Pie
    US$3.25
  • Chocolate Cream Pie
    US$3.25
  • Coconut Custard Pie
    US$3.25
  • Brownie
    US$2.95
  • Ruggalach
  • Danish Pastry
  • Layer Cake
  • Linzer Tart
  • Napoleon
  • Lemon Meringue Pie
  • Pound Cake
  • Strawberry Short Cake
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

Fountain

  • Ice Cream Soda
  • Milk Shake
  • Egg Cream

Ice Cream

  • Dish of Ice Cream
  • Banana Split
    US$6.50
  • Sundae
    US$5.25

Puddings

  • Rice Pudding
    US$2.95
  • Chocolate Pudding
    US$2.95
  • Bread Pudding
    US$2.95
  • Jello
    US$2.75

Beverages

  • Coffee or Tea
    US$1.15
  • Decaffeinated Coffee
    US$1.20
  • Herbal Tea
    US$1.35
  • Iced Coffee or Tea

    reg or decaf

    US$1.95
  • Cappuccino
    US$3.50
  • Iced Cappuccino
    US$4.25
  • Espresso
    US$2.50
  • Milk
    US$1.95
  • Chocolate Milk
    US$2.10
  • Hot Chocolate

    with whipped cream

    US$1.35
  • Lemonade
    US$1.95
  • Seltzer
    US$1.50
  • Bottled Water
    US$1.75
  • Fruit Punch
    US$1.95

Beverages - Soda

  • Pepsi
    US$1.95
  • Diet Pepsi
    US$1.95
  • Orange
    US$1.95
  • 7 Up or Ginger Ale

    with one refill

    US$1.95

From the Bar - Cordials and Sherries

  • Harvey's Bristol Cream
    US$7.95
  • Grand Marnier
    US$7.95
  • Long Island Iced Tea
    US$7.95
  • Spritzer Wine and Soda
    US$4.95
  • Amaretto
    US$7.95
  • Dry Sack
    US$7.95
  • Anisette
    US$7.95
  • Creme De Cacao
    US$7.95
  • Galliano
    US$7.95
  • Kahlua
    US$7.95
  • Midori
    US$7.95
  • Sloe Gin
    US$7.95
  • Sambuca Romano
    US$7.95
  • Drambuie
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Brandies and Cognacs

  • Apricot Brandy
    US$7.95
  • Black Berry Brandy
    US$7.95
  • Ouzo
    US$7.95
  • Metaxa
    US$7.95
  • Courvoisier
    US$7.95
  • Remy Martin Vs
    US$7.95
  • Hennessy
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Specialty Coffees

  • Irish

    with whiskey

    US$7.95
  • Jamaican

    with rum

    US$7.95
  • Mexican

    with kahlua

    US$7.95

From the Bar - Gin and Vodka

  • Beefeater
    US$7.95
  • Tanqueray
    US$7.95
  • Vodka
    US$7.95
  • Smirnoff
    US$7.95
  • Absolut
    US$7.95
  • Stolichnaya
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Rum

  • Bacardi
    US$7.95
  • Malibu
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Bourbon

  • Jack Daniels
    US$7.95
  • Wild Turkey
    US$7.95
  • Southern Comfort
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Whiskey

  • Canadian Club
    US$7.95
  • Seagrams
    US$7.95
  • Seagrams Vo
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Scotch

  • J and B
    US$7.95
  • Cutty Sark
    US$7.95
  • Johnnie Walker Red
    US$7.95
  • Johnnie Walker Black
    US$7.95
  • Chivas Regal
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Cocktails and Mixed Drinks

  • Manhattan
    US$7.95
  • Martini
    US$7.95
  • Old Fashion
    US$7.95
  • Rob Roy
    US$7.95
  • Whiskey, Scotch or Apricot Sour
    US$7.95
  • Tequila Sunrise
    US$7.95
  • Sombrero
    US$7.95
  • Scotch or Rye
    US$7.95
  • Melon Ball
    US$7.95
  • Rusty Nail
    US$7.95
  • Black Russian
    US$7.95
  • White Russian
    US$7.95
  • Tom Collins
    US$7.95
  • Singapore Sling
    US$7.95
  • Screw Driver
    US$7.95
  • Gin and Tonic
    US$7.95
  • Seven and Seved
    US$7.95
  • Madres
    US$7.95
  • Bloody Mary
    US$7.95
  • Sex on the Beach
    US$7.95
  • Toasted Almond
    US$7.95
  • Brandy Alexander
    US$7.95
  • Sea Breeze - Bay Breeze
    US$7.95

From the Bar - Wines

  • Red Wines
  • White Wines
  • Rose Wines

From the Bar - Beers

  • Domestic
    US$3.95
  • Imported
    US$4.50
  • Non-Alcoholic
    US$3.95