New Hyde Park Diner
Welcome to the New Hyde Park Diner, a beloved local gem nestled at 160 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY. This charming diner stands out not just for its scrumptious offerings but also for its warm and inviting atmosphere that creates a nostalgic dining experience reminiscent of classic New York diners.
Step inside and you are immediately greeted by a friendly host, setting the tone for the exceptional service you can expect throughout your meal. The bright, spacious interior is adorned with big windows and a cozy 70s vibe, making it a comfortable spot for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. The booths even come with charming little jukeboxes—a delightful nod to the diner culture of yesteryear. Cleanliness is a top priority here, ensuring that your dining experience is both pleasant and hygienic.
The menu at New Hyde Park Diner is as enticing as the atmosphere, offering a full range of classic diner fare. Start your day with their hearty breakfast options, or indulge in a satisfying lunch or dinner. Guests rave about the fresh, hot food served in generous portions. You can wash it all down with a refreshing soda, with options like Pepsi and Diet Pepsi at just $1.95. For those looking to unwind, the bar selections feature a variety of bourbons and scotches, all priced at a very reasonable $7.95.
Reviewers are especially fond of the standout menu items like the tuna melt on pita, a dish so good you’ll want to take the leftovers home, and the classic milkshakes that have become a nostalgic favorite among customers. Sheryl Santos-Hatchett, PhD, fondly recalled her experience of enjoying cheese blintzes—something she missed since moving from New York to Texas—which highlights the diner’s ability to evoke cherished memories through its cooking.
Customer testimonials reflect the consistent excellence in both food and service. Crystal Lilly notes that the attentive wait staff and quick service elevate the dining experience, while Steven Townsend appreciates the friendly demeanor of the staff, turning a simple meal into something truly memorable. The diner has earned praise for serving everything from breakfast to late-night snacks with unwavering quality and speed, making it a favorite for locals and travelers alike.
Whether you’re in the mood for a late-night bite or a leisurely breakfast, the New Hyde Park Diner is ready to welcome you with open arms and satisfy your cravings. Next time you find yourself in New Hyde Park or passing through, make sure to stop by and enjoy a dining experience that’s more than just a meal; it’s a journey back to the classic diner culture of New York. With delicious food, attentive service, and a cozy atmosphere, you’ll quickly understand why this diner has garnered such a loyal following.
- Homemade ChiliUS$5.95
- Apple, Cherry or Blueberry PieUS$3.25
- Apple Crumb CakeUS$3.25
- Apple TurnoverUS$3.25
- Banana Cream PieUS$3.25
- Boston Cream PieUS$3.25
- Chocolate Cream PieUS$3.25
- Coconut Custard PieUS$3.25
- BrownieUS$2.95
- Ruggalach
- Danish Pastry
- Layer Cake
- Linzer Tart
- Napoleon
- Lemon Meringue Pie
- Pound Cake
- Strawberry Short Cake
- Chocolate Chip Cookie
- Ice Cream Soda
- Milk Shake
- Egg Cream
- Dish of Ice Cream
- Banana SplitUS$6.50
- SundaeUS$5.25
- Rice PuddingUS$2.95
- Chocolate PuddingUS$2.95
- Bread PuddingUS$2.95
- JelloUS$2.75
- Coffee or TeaUS$1.15
- Decaffeinated CoffeeUS$1.20
- Herbal TeaUS$1.35
- Iced Coffee or TeaUS$1.95
- CappuccinoUS$3.50
- Iced CappuccinoUS$4.25
- EspressoUS$2.50
- MilkUS$1.95
- Chocolate MilkUS$2.10
- Hot ChocolateUS$1.35
- LemonadeUS$1.95
- SeltzerUS$1.50
- Bottled WaterUS$1.75
- Fruit PunchUS$1.95
- PepsiUS$1.95
- Diet PepsiUS$1.95
- OrangeUS$1.95
- 7 Up or Ginger AleUS$1.95
- Harvey's Bristol CreamUS$7.95
- Grand MarnierUS$7.95
- Long Island Iced TeaUS$7.95
- Spritzer Wine and SodaUS$4.95
- AmarettoUS$7.95
- Dry SackUS$7.95
- AnisetteUS$7.95
- Creme De CacaoUS$7.95
- GallianoUS$7.95
- KahluaUS$7.95
- MidoriUS$7.95
- Sloe GinUS$7.95
- Sambuca RomanoUS$7.95
- DrambuieUS$7.95
- Apricot BrandyUS$7.95
- Black Berry BrandyUS$7.95
- OuzoUS$7.95
- MetaxaUS$7.95
- CourvoisierUS$7.95
- Remy Martin VsUS$7.95
- HennessyUS$7.95
- IrishUS$7.95
- JamaicanUS$7.95
- MexicanUS$7.95
- BeefeaterUS$7.95
- TanquerayUS$7.95
- VodkaUS$7.95
- SmirnoffUS$7.95
- AbsolutUS$7.95
- StolichnayaUS$7.95
- BacardiUS$7.95
- MalibuUS$7.95
- Jack DanielsUS$7.95
- Wild TurkeyUS$7.95
- Southern ComfortUS$7.95
- Canadian ClubUS$7.95
- SeagramsUS$7.95
- Seagrams VoUS$7.95
- J and BUS$7.95
- Cutty SarkUS$7.95
- Johnnie Walker RedUS$7.95
- Johnnie Walker BlackUS$7.95
- Chivas RegalUS$7.95
- ManhattanUS$7.95
- MartiniUS$7.95
- Old FashionUS$7.95
- Rob RoyUS$7.95
- Whiskey, Scotch or Apricot SourUS$7.95
- Tequila SunriseUS$7.95
- SombreroUS$7.95
- Scotch or RyeUS$7.95
- Melon BallUS$7.95
- Rusty NailUS$7.95
- Black RussianUS$7.95
- White RussianUS$7.95
- Tom CollinsUS$7.95
- Singapore SlingUS$7.95
- Screw DriverUS$7.95
- Gin and TonicUS$7.95
- Seven and SevedUS$7.95
- MadresUS$7.95
- Bloody MaryUS$7.95
- Sex on the BeachUS$7.95
- Toasted AlmondUS$7.95
- Brandy AlexanderUS$7.95
- Sea Breeze - Bay BreezeUS$7.95
- Red Wines
- White Wines
- Rose Wines
- DomesticUS$3.95
- ImportedUS$4.50
- Non-AlcoholicUS$3.95
898 Reviews
12 Sep 2025
09 Sep 2025
08 Aug 2025
24 Jul 2025
23 Jul 2025
17 Jul 2025
09 Jul 2025
03 Jun 2025
Caffe Greco
Mye's Ribs Filipino Kitchen
Rella's Italian Tavern
Vero Chicago Pizza
Join the New Hyde Park Diner Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.